BAA215 – Business and Corporate Law Assessment Item 1 – Case Study 2
Case Study 2 – Karacal Kitchens
Task Length No more than 1500 words – approximately 500 words per question
Link to Units LOs:
As listed on page 5 in the unit outline and on the attached rubric.
Refer to table on page 5 in the unit outline
Due Date: Due 23 May 2019 at 2pm
• Kara & Karl Kelsey – owners of Karacal Kitchens
• Barry Brickle – Karls cousin and retiring employee of Karacal Kitchens
• Adrian Anthill – friend of Kara and Karl and recently qualified kitchen designer • Barbara Black – friend of Kara and Karl
Kara and Karl Kelsey own and operate Karacal Kitchens, a small business operating from premises at Coleman Street in Moonah. The business custom designs, manufactures and installs bespoke kitchens. The business began operating in 2010 and by the end of 2018 it employed two cabinet makers and two designers.
Up until March 2019 Barry Brickle had worked for Karacal Kitchens. He lent the partnership $100 000 when it commenced business. Kara, Karl and Barry have all agreed that it is time that Barry stopped working for the partnership and for him to be repaid his $100 000.
In order to repay Barry this money Kara and Kelsey are considering registering a company and expanding the business to include friends Barbara and Adrian. Adrian has recently finished qualifications in design and manufacture and Barbara has always spoken about wanting to become involved in Karacal Kitchens in some capacity if the opportunity ever arose.
Adrian, Barbara, Karl and Kara meet and decide that they wish to incorporate a company. They propose:
1. That two directors be appointed – Kara and Adrian. They will each also be employed by the company to work 40 hours per week;
2. That 150 shares be issued at $2 000 per share.
3. That the existing partnership assets are worth $200 000;
4. That Barry Brickle is owed $100 000 that needs to be repaid from any funds raised by the registration of the company and the creation of shares;
5. That Adrian purchase 25 shares with the payment of $50 000;
6. That Barbara purchase 25 shares with the payment of $50 000;
7. That Karl and Kara each ‘acquire’ 50 shares by selling the partnership assets to the company;
8. That the company set a dividend policy that provides that 50% of any profit that the company makes each year is returned to the shareholders in proportion with their shareholding;
9. That the company consider fundraising at the end of 2020 should they need to borrow any funds to expand their operations and move from their current rental premises in Coleman Street.
You are approached by Adrian and Barbara who seek advice on the following issues:
1. What type of company structure would you suggest is the most appropriate and why?
2. What is the role of the ‘replaceable rules’ and the benefits, or otherwise of adopting a constitution for any company that they may establish. What are the ways that a constitution can be adopted and the major legal limits that exist in relation to altering a constitution?
3. Does the Corporations Act 2001 (Cth) mandate that companies need to have regular meetings? Barbara works as a geologist and spends at least three months of the year out of the country. How can she participate in meetings during her time overseas?
4. What options would be available to Barbara should she decide to sell her shares in the company at a later date, should her work as a geologist mean that she is unable to remain involved in the business? Are there mechanisms that can be put in place at the time that the company is registered to deal with how and to whom she may sell her shares?
5. What are the basic duties of directors and are they different for directors that work within the business and those that are not directly ‘hands on’ within the business?
6. What liability might the directors face should any of the kitchens that they install be faulty and cause injury to customers?
You must answer question 1 plus any two other questions (Three questions in total)
Please use case law and/or legislation to illustrate your answers.
Prepare your answers in report format, in any way that informs the parties of their legal obligations and/or rights in relation to the proposed incorporation.
Simone Bingham - UC BAA215
RUBRIC BFA1AA – Assessment Task 1 – Case Study 1
CRITERIA HD (High Distinction) DN (Distinction) CR (Credit) PP (Pass) NN (Fail)
LO 1 Explain business and corporate law principles and critique its application. Describe and explain business law concepts and principles. 4/20 Full and comprehensive demonstration of understanding of business and corporate law concepts and principles Comprehensive demonstration of understanding of business and corporate law concepts and principles A good demonstration of understanding of business and corporate law concepts and principles ome evidence of the
understanding of business and corporate law concepts and principles Minimal demonstration of understanding of
this learning outcome
Explain legislation and the common law and critique how it can used to answer legal problems 4/20 An excellent understanding of how the law can be used to answer legal problems A good understanding of how the law can be used to answer legal problems Some understanding of the how the law can be used to answer legal problems Minimal demonstration of understanding of
this learning outcome
LO 2 Apply business and corporate law to authentic legal situations Apply basic legal problem-solving techniques and legal rules to case studies to provide advice using legal reasoning, judgement, rules and sources. 4/20 Excellent ability to apply legal problem-solving techniques and legal rules to provide advice. Included is an excellent ability to use legal reasoning, judgement and appropriate rules and legal sources Effective application of legal problem-solving techniques and legal rules to provide advice. Included is a good ability to use legal reasoning, judgement and appropriate rules and legal sources Minimal demonstration of understanding of
this learning outcome
Research academic articles, business and corporate law web pages and other material to inform and assist in resolving complex authentic business law and corporate legal situation. 4/20 A comprehensive use of appropriate academic articles, business and corporate law web pages and other material to inform and assist in resolving complex authentic business law and
corporate legal situation Good use of appropriate academic articles, business and corporate law web pages and other material to inform and assist in resolving complex authentic business law and corporate legal situation Minimal demonstration of understanding of this learning outcome
LO 3 Present advice in oral and written forms on authentic business and corporate law case studies Communicate written advice in the appropriate for, including in report format as applicable for the recipient business person or stakeholder 4/20
An excellent ability to communicate written advice in the appropriate format for the relevant audience
A good ability to communicate written advice in the appropriate format for the relevant audience
Minimal demonstration of understanding of learning outcome